Theres so many toys out there. We focus on dogs toys that float and throw well as our dogs love retrieving. We also avoid those that are potentially toxic or could harm our dogs or yours. We are also aware that dogs also love a cuddle toy and obsess about carry some around. So all our toys have been approved by our dogs.. or stolen from our stock room which gives us an idea that they are the really good ones! Our garden is like a little rock festival with collapsed 'Shazzas' all over the place! They seem to like those that you can shake around .. or I suppose 'kill' would be a more honest description...anyway get any of these.. they are all great!